How Can We Learn Whether Firm Policies are Working in Africa? Challenges (and Solutions?) for Experiments and Structural Models

Firm productivity is low in African countries, prompting governments to try a number of active policies to improve it. Yet despite the millions of dollars spent on these policies, we are far from a situation where we know whether many of them are yielding the desired payoffs. This paper establishes...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Author: McKenzie, David
Format: eBook
Language:English
Published: Washington, D.C The World Bank 2011
Online Access:
Collection: World Bank E-Library Archive - Collection details see MPG.ReNa
LEADER 01965nmm a2200217 u 4500
001 EB002100045
003 EBX01000000000000001240135
005 00000000000000.0
007 cr|||||||||||||||||||||
008 221013 ||| eng
100 1 |a McKenzie, David 
245 0 0 |a How Can We Learn Whether Firm Policies are Working in Africa?  |h Elektronische Ressource  |b Challenges (and Solutions?) for Experiments and Structural Models  |c David McKenzie 
260 |a Washington, D.C  |b The World Bank  |c 2011 
300 |a 26 p 
700 1 |a McKenzie, David 
041 0 7 |a eng  |2 ISO 639-2 
989 |b WOBA  |a World Bank E-Library Archive 
028 5 0 |a 10.1596/1813-9450-5632 
856 4 0 |u http://elibrary.worldbank.org/doi/book/10.1596/1813-9450-5632  |x Verlag  |3 Volltext 
082 0 |a 330 
520 |a Firm productivity is low in African countries, prompting governments to try a number of active policies to improve it. Yet despite the millions of dollars spent on these policies, we are far from a situation where we know whether many of them are yielding the desired payoffs. This paper establishes some basic facts about the number and heterogeneity of firms in different sub-Saharan African countries and discusses their implications for experimental and structural approaches towards trying to estimate firm policy impacts. It shows that the typical firm program such as a matching grant scheme or business training program involves only 100 to 300 firms, which are often very heterogeneous in terms of employment and sales levels. As a result, standard experimental designs will lack any power to detect reasonable sized treatment impacts, while structural models which assume common production technologies and few missing markets will be ill-suited to capture the key constraints firms face. Nevertheless, the author suggests a way forward which involves focusing on a more homogeneous sub-sample of firms and collecting a lot more data on them than is typically collected